If there’s one thing I’ve learned over my years of baking, it’s that there’s something incredibly special about icebox cakes. The cool, creamy, and downright scrumptious desserts have a way of making every occasion feel festive, even if it’s just a hot summer day at home. I remember the first time I tried my hand at making a strawberry icebox cake—it was a revelation!
The combination of crisp, refreshing flavors with rich creaminess was just what I needed on a warm afternoon.
In this listicle, I’ll share 27 fantastic icebox cake recipes that truly deserve a spot in your dessert repertoire. After experimenting with several variations,from fruity to chocolaty, I can confidently say these recipes are tried, tested, and absolutely delightful. Whether you’re looking for something to impress guests or simply want to treat yourself after a long day, I guarantee you’ll find something you love here.
These icebox cakes require minimal effort with unforgettable results. It’s all about layering flavors and textures that meld together beautifully with just a little time in the fridge. You’ll find a variety of recipes to suit every palate, and I’m excited to take you through each one.
So, grab your favorite baking dish, and let’s dive into these delicious creations!
1. Strawberry Icebox Cake
First up, we have the Strawberry Icebox Cake from Cakes Hungry. This cake is a slice of summer sunshine, bursting with fresh strawberry flavor and incredibly light whipped cream. The best part?
It’s no-bake, making it a go-to recipe for those sweltering hot days when turning on the oven is the last thing you want to do.
What I adore about this cake is how effortlessly it comes together. Just layer those strawberries between the cream and graham crackers, and watch as it transforms into a stunning dessert in the fridge! You’ll be amazed at how the flavors develop after chilling, making it a showstopper for any casual get-together.
Trust me, every bite feels like a refreshing delight!
2. Key Lime Icebox Cake
Next, we have the zesty and refreshing Key Lime Icebox Cake featured at Cakes Hungry. This delightful dessert balances the tang of key limes with a sweet and creamy filling that will transport your taste buds to a tropical paradise in every bite.
As someone who loves a good balance of flavors, I find this cake so enjoyable because it’s not overly sweet. The graham cracker crust adds a wonderful crunch, perfectly complementing the smooth lime filling. Perfect for a warm afternoon, when you need just the right amount of sweetness!
3. Lotus Biscoff Icebox Cake
Coming in hot is the Lotus Biscoff Icebox Cake from Cakes Hungry. If you’ve ever had those irresistible cookie butters, you’re going to fall head over heels for this cake. The unique flavor of Biscoff cookies paired with a rich creaminess creates a totally indulgent experience.
I love how simple it is to make—just layer the cookies and cream, and let the fridge do the rest. It transforms into a creamy, dreamy dessert that’s perfect for any occasion (or no occasion at all!). Don’t be surprised if you find yourself going back for seconds; it’s that good!
4. Banana Split Icebox Cake
Next, let’s dive into the classic Banana Split Icebox Cake found on Simple and Seasonal. If you’re a fan of the beloved ice cream treat, you’ll love this take on it! Layers of bananas, whipped cream, and a graham cracker crust come together to form a brilliant dessert.
The bananas add a natural sweetness, while the cream keeps things light and fluffy. This is a perfect dish to satisfy those nostalgic cravings! The layering process is fun too; you can get a bit creative with it and even add your favorite toppings.
You’ll definitely be the hero of dessert time!
5. Classic Icebox Cake
Another must-try is the Classic Icebox Cake from Recipe Rebel. This recipe highlights the beauty of simple ingredients coming together for a delightful treat. With layers of cream and chocolate wafers, this cake is so easy to make and comes with a nostalgia kick.
What I love about the classic version is its versatility. You can customize it to incorporate your favorite flavors or cookies. Each jar can become a unique masterpiece!
It captures the heart of homemade desserts in the most delightful way.
6. Banana Split Icebox Cake (Again!)
Now, don’t be surprised to find another Banana Split Icebox Cake again on The Girl Who Ate Everything. This version is simply heavenly, combining fresh banana, whipped cream, and chocolate goodness with a graham cracker base.
I adore how decadent yet refreshing it feels. It’s like indulging in summer every time you take a bite. Perfect for brunch, or just because, this recipe has become a favorite in my household!
You’ll be tempted to make it again and again.
7. 3-Ingredient Icebox Cake
Simplicity at its finest is what you’ll find with this 3-Ingredient Icebox Cake from Yummy Toddler Food. Honestly, who can resist a dessert that’s so easy to whip up? All you need is some ladyfingers, pudding, and whipped cream — and voila!
Not only is it incredibly simple, but it’s also super flexible. You can play around with flavors and make it your own. I love making this on those busy evenings when a sweet craving strikes, and I need something quick yet delightful to satisfy it!
8. No-Bake Banana Split Icebox Cake
You guessed it; we have another** No-Bake Banana Split Icebox Cake** from Spend with Pennies. What’s not to love? This dish embraces all the good stuff—banana, chocolate, and whipped cream—without the hassle of baking.
Each layer offers a different texture that matches perfectly! It’s an interactive dessert where each bite feels celebratory and inviting. Perfect for when you’re craving something light and sweet without all the fuss!
9. Berry Icebox Cake
Delight in the fresh flavors of the Berry Icebox Cake, which you’ll find on Sally’s Baking Addiction. The medley of vibrant berries adds a refreshing twist to the traditional icebox cake, offering a feast for both the eyes and the taste buds.
I appreciate how berries bring a natural brightness to the dish, and the creaminess balances it out beautifully. It’s a great choice when you want something light and fruity! Plus, it’s such a stunning dessert to present, and it tastes even better after a few hours in the fridge.
10. Banana Split Icebox Cake 1
Surprise! Another fantastic take on the Banana Split Icebox Cake appears here as featured on Woman Scribbles. With every recipe, you’re treated to a slightly different spin, and trust me, this one is no exception.
It manages to marry all the beloved flavors together, making it a delightful experience. Bananas, whipped topping, and delicious chocolate all come together for a creamy, dreamy treat that’s hard to resist. If you’re aiming to make everyone smile, this is your go-to cake!
11. Banana Split Icebox Cake 2
I know, another rendition of the Banana Split Icebox Cake by Life, Love and Sugar. Honestly, I can’t help myself! The various methods of assembling this cake yield unique textures and tastes, all worth savoring.
Combining different toppings and layers, this cake gives you a touch of creativity in every bite. Whether you’re indulging alone or planning a family treat, this recipe stands out even in multiple variations. Embrace this creamy delight that brings smiles all around!
12. Banana Split Icebox Cake 3
You’ve guessed it! Here’s yet another variation from Ann’s Entitled Life. I just can’t get enough of the different flavors mixed up in each recipe!
This one brings a sweet indulgence that’s reminiscent of childhood fun.
The layers give it a whole new character, and it is absolutely delicious chilled. The large servings allow you to share this treat, and I always encourage you to enjoy it with the people you love! So go ahead, make this recipe and become a dessert rockstar!
13. Icebox Cake for Grandma
Celebrate with the Icebox Cake featured in Brown Eyed Baker. What I love about this cake is the nostalgic memories it brings to the table.
It’s a perfect way to honor tradition while enjoying a simple yet delicious treat. Creamy layers filled with delightful flavors that are sure to elicit heartfelt stories and giggles! Every slice feels like a warm hug from home, so you’ll want to keep this recipe in your back pocket.
14. Eclair Cake
Explore the unique Eclair Cake from Delish. If you adore éclairs, you’ll absolutely adore this icebox cake version! The flavors are reminiscent of a classic eclair, but layered like a cake.
I love how the chocolate ganache topping adds that extra indulgent touch. It feels like you’re treating yourself to a fancy dessert without any fuss! This cake fully embraces “less is more,” proving you don’t need over-the-top ingredients to achieve greatness.
15. Banana Split Icebox Cake (Seriously, Last One!)
This is for real—this last Banana Split Icebox Cake from Taste of Home captures the essence of summer in the most fantastic way possible. The light creamy layers, vibrant bananas, and rich chocolate sauce all come together to create a delightful adventure in dessert.
I’ve shared this dessert with friends, and they always rave about how refreshing and satisfying it is! It’s a gentle reminder to embrace comfort food that requires very little effort. This recipe will be a favorite for sure—believe me, you’ll love it too!
16. Banana Pudding Icebox Cake
If you’re a banana pudding fan (and who isn’t?), you’ll want to make the Banana Pudding Icebox Cake from Delish. This unique cake is made with layers of creamy banana pudding and whipped cream that takes the common flavors and elevates them to new heights!
I love how this recipe melds the sweetness of bananas with the smoothness of pudding—every bite is a memory-filled experience. It’s delightful and comforting—a total crowd-pleaser that you can serve at any occasion!
17. Classic Icebox Cake
Don’t overlook the Icebox Cake from Taste of Home. The classic flavors here remind you that sometimes, timeless recipes hold the most charm. With layers of whipped cream and your choice of cookies or cake, you have a tasty treat that feels like home.
Each bite brings a nostalgic feeling that never fails to bring smiles. You can even make it in advance, so it’s perfect for those busy days when you want something sweet without the last-minute fuss. You will simply adore this one!
18. Lemon Icebox Cake
Brighten your days with the zesty Lemon Icebox Cake recipe found on Delish. The refreshing flavors of lemon make it a fabulous treat for warm days—or any time you want a hint of brightness in your dessert.
The citrus coupled with the creamy layers is delicious, invigorating, and light. It’s especially satisfying after a nourishing meal, bringing a sweet, bright finish that’s simply delightful. Get ready for rave reviews when you serve this flavor-packed beauty!
19. Raspberry Cheesecake Lasagna
Take a twist on a classic with the Raspberry Cheesecake Lasagna from Delish. This delightful dessert packs in layers of creamy cheesecake and tart raspberries, bringing a burst of flavor in every bite—trust me, you’re going to love it!
The beauty of this recipe is in its presentation. With vibrant colors and flavors that play beautifully together, it’s sure to impress anyone lucky enough to try it! I can’t recommend this one enough for gatherings where you want to wow your guests!
20. Peanut Butter Oreo Icebox Cake
For all the chocolate and peanut butter lovers, Peanut Butter Oreo Icebox Cake from Delish is downright heavenly! The combination of flavors is nothing short of divine, and I can attest that it’s a true indulgence.
I love how rich this dessert feels, thanks to the layers of creamy peanut butter combined with the classic Oreo crunch. It’s a favorite in my household, and every slice disappears faster than I anticipate! So prepare for a mix of flavors that will keep everyone coming back for more!
21. Creme de Menthe Squares
If minty freshness is what you crave, then the Creme de Menthe Squares from Taste of Home will put a smile on your face. This dessert combines the refreshing taste of mint with creamy chocolate layers for an indulgent snack or dessert.
I love serving this one after a meal—it’s perfectly light with a pop of flavor that leaves everyone feeling refreshed! It’s an easy-to-prepare, no-bake dessert that’s equally perfect for home or gatherings, delivering joy in each square.
22. Frozen Mocha Marbled Loaf
Take your love for coffee to the next level with my next pick, the Frozen Mocha Marbled Loaf from Taste of Home. The combination of mocha flavor and the creamy marbled layers is enough to awaken your taste buds.
This one is not just a feast for the palate but also visually impressive! It’s a fantastic dessert to share and savor after a delightful meal, too. This cake will elevate your dessert game and surely become a favorite among coffee lovers!
23. S’mores Lasagna
Experience summer by indulging in S’mores Lasagna featured on Delish. This dish captures the campfire nostalgia in a cool and creamy cake form, and I can’t get enough of it!
Layers of chocolate, marshmallows, and graham crackers create the perfect combination that feels both cozy and adventurous. It’s perfect for easy summer gatherings—or any time of year when you want that classic s’mores flavor without the campfire!
24. Strawberry Icebox Cake 2
Yes, we are revisiting the Strawberry Icebox Cake with another delicious version from Taste of Home. The freshness of the berries paired with a creamy filling makes this cake a perennial favorite!
I swear, once you serve this everyone will be asking for the recipe—it’s truly something special. I love this version because it balances sweet and tangy flavors so brilliantly, making it a refreshing delight. Perfect for those sunny afternoons!
25. Blueberry Cheesecake Icebox Cake
Let’s take another journey into the berry world with the delightful Blueberry Cheesecake Icebox Cake from Delish. Packed with delightful layered flavors, this cheesecake creation is truly irresistible!
The delightful combination of blueberry and smooth cheesecake is refreshingly delicious, offering a delicate sweetness that’s perfect for gatherings or simply a sweet treat for yourself. Prepare to be asked for seconds!
26. Giant Peanut Butter Ice Cream Sandwich
As we wind down our list, take notice of the colossal Giant Peanut Butter Ice Cream Sandwich from Taste of Home. Who wouldn’t want a dessert that doubles as a party centerpiece?
The combination of creamy ice cream with delicious peanut butter cookies will make your head spin! It’s playful, indulgent, and the perfect way to impress both children and adults alike. Making this giant treat is a fun way to celebrate summer days!
27. Pina Colada Lasagna
To wrap things up, let’s enjoy the tropical vibes with the Pina Colada Lasagna from Delish. This dessert takes you straight to paradise with its layers of tropical goodness!
Each bite has the dynamic flavors of piña colada—coconut and pineapple—combined in the creamy indulgence of a chilled dessert. It’s a fun escape from the ordinary, and I bet you’ll find it hard to resist going back for another slice!
Conclusion
In summary, these 27 icebox cake recipes are designed to satisfy your sweet cravings while bringing a little joy into your baking routine. Each one offers something unique, whether it’s a fruity burst or a creamy delight.
One personal favorite you’d often find in my fridge is the Key Lime Icebox Cake. Its zesty notes are perfect for any day of the week! I’ve had so much fun baking these recipes and hope you do too.
Which one are you excited to try first? I’d love to hear your thoughts, so leave a comment below.
